One Man Businesses Are Inherently Noncapitalist

Stalin Tonks: All this talk about donations and paywalls makes you sound like a capitalist, Robert. I am so disappointed in you.

First of all, I live in a capitalist country. You have to do what you have to do survive in whatever country you live in. If you want to survive in a capitalist country, you have to play by the rules of capitalism. And it’s not anti-socialist to be rich or to invest in or own businesses. For instance, the FMLN revolutionaries owned and invested in businesses, farms and ranches all over Latin America. All of the money went for revolution – guns, bombs, uniforms, supplies, wages for soldiers, etc. The father of the famous terrorist Carlos was a Venezuelan millionaire and Communist. That’s not a contradiction, and he doesn’t have to give all his money away. A Communist can be rich in a capitalist country. I would like to think he would do good things with his money though and not use it to rip off the people or exploit workers. Engels was a rich businessman.

I am not a capitalist. No exploitation, no capitalism. I am simply a worker selling his labor on the open market. All one man businesses are noncapitalist. It’s just one guy selling his labor on the market mostly to other workers. It’s workers paying other workers for some service. Also I am not marking anything up, although the profit motive and marking up products as a middleman is not necessarily capitalist and is completely compatible with socialism. I also feel that small businesses are an important part of a socialist country.

Anyway, I’m not really a Communist. I am just a socialist, and I am OK with social democracy where you have private businesses and even corporations and where up to 93% of the economy is private owned, as in Sweden for instance.

Democratic socialism allows a lot of capitalism in it. It just modified it and regulates it, and that is the socialist part as capitalists accept no limits whatsoever on their profits. Any state that limits the profits of Capital is automatically acting in a socialist manner. All regulation of business is inherently socialist. It has to be. Capitalists do not accept the state regulating their businesses to limit their profits in any way, shape or form. That’s their nature.

4 Comments

Filed under Capitalism, Economics, Government, Latin America, Left, Maoism, Marxism, Regional, Revolution, Socialism, South America, Venezuela

4 responses to “One Man Businesses Are Inherently Noncapitalist

  1. George Jolly

    To the disciples of our current neoliberal capitalism, us socialists might as well be dyed in the wool Stalinists. The lack of understanding of socialism in this country is remarkable. I think climate change, particularly climate driven refugees, will end global capitalism and allow Americans to develop a relationship with socialist policy and ideaology.

    • Thank you comrade. Yep, it shows how insane capitalism is. The capitalists would rather blow up the whole planet than see a cut in their profits. They’re suicidally blinded by money.

    • On the contrary, I think Americans will double down on Capitalism. After all, there are plenty of opportunities for people to sell products and solutions to adapt to climate change. There is money to be made from adaptation, none from prevention.

      Capitalists will argue that now, more than ever, we need free enterprise to solve major issues, and that the market is best placed to solve the problem that the (ahem) Government created.

  2. Mayur Varshne

    Sole proprietors can thrive only if they are selling highly specialized services.

    Survival is not a big issue for anybody in the developed economies in which there is a large demand for almost everything.

    The biggest argument in favour of capitalism is that it quite rewards enterprise, innovation, specialization and hard work. It is, of course, heavily biased in favour of the capitalist, especially in the case of heavily populated, developing countries which have an excess of almost every kind of labour.

    10 $ for unrestricted access to your blog for a lifetime is, indeed, quite demanding! As a matter of fact, 10 $ is a princely sum, everywhere.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s