Risks of Insertive Anal Sex

erikthered: Is anal with a woman safer than with a man?

You mean penetrating? I guess you mean being the penetrator and not the one being penetrated. Insertive anal sex is as risky with a man as with a woman, but no one quite knows even how risky insertive anal sex is anyway. Figures coming out of the gay community show that it does carry some risk, but it is far less risky than receptive anal sex. A friend of mine knows a gay man who says he did some research and now he has lots of gay sex with lots of men and he hasn’t gotten HIV yet. He said he only tops, and he never bottoms. He’s topped hundreds of gay men this way in recent years. Surely some of them were HIV positive.

There is at least one case in the porn world of a straight actor who got HIV from insertive sex on a porn set with some transsexual person or pre-op tranny or whatever the Hell it was. The actor got HIV from insertive anal with him/her/whatever.

There is another guy in porn who says he got it from a woman, but he doesn’t say how he got it.

Men are at risk of female-male HIV transmission in cases of penile and vaginal bleeding. The Padian Study in 1989 followed a number of HIV-serodiscordant heterosexual couples in which either the male or the female was HIV positive. Over a five year period through ~700 sex acts, 20% of the men had gotten HIV from their wives. This means that a man would have to have sex with an HIV positive woman 2,800 times in order to get HIV. Even after a man has sex with an HIV positive woman 40 times, he still only has a 1% chance of getting HIV. You have a 99% chance of not getting HIV even after having sex with an HIV positive woman 40 times for God’s sake!

In the Padian Study, female-male HIV transmission was highly correlated with episodes of vaginal and penile bleeding. Therefore it appears that the presence of blood during the sex act appears important in female-male HIV transmission. This makes sense as HIV is a blood-borne illness. Most people tend to forget that. Semen is only so transmissible because it is full of blood (little known fact).

I have studied titer levels needed to transmit HIV, and looking at HIV titers of HIV positive women in the US, I am a bit baffled at how it even transmits because the levels seem to low to transmit.

Vaginal titers are quite a  bit higher in HIV positive prostitutes in Thailand and this makes sense as female-male transmission is happening a lot more over there. But even in Thailand, most female-male HIV transmission was found to be occurring due to vaginal bleeding in prostitutes servicing too many man a day. Even with that going on, the recent introduction of condoms reduced nearly eliminated that transmission. So condoms appear to be effective even in the presence of vaginal bleeding.  This also makes sense if female-male HIV transmission is going via blood instead of vaginal fluid.

In addition, the urethra appears to be an inefficient vehicle to receive HIV. Anal and vaginal walls which may experience tiny tears are much better for transmission, especially the former. Anal walls are much more susceptible to tiny tears and microscopic bleeding than vaginal walls are, hence insertive anal sex would seem to put the insertive partner at greater risk due to increased chances of exposure to blood via the anus of the partner. This is probably the reason for the somewhat elevated risk from anal sex.


Filed under Asia, Biology, Health, Heterosexuality, Homosexuality, Illness, Pornography, Public Health, Regional, Science, SE Asia, Sex, Thailand

17 responses to “Risks of Insertive Anal Sex

  1. Slim

    I always thought that Tommy Morrison and Magic Johnson got their HIV from eating pussy, which they very well could have, instead of getting shit on their dicks.

  2. Lin

    I suggest technology should help:

    A plug & play gadget consisting of 2 parts:

      1) A small gauge inserter/receiver or a modified electric cattle prod. Form factor could be customized.

      2) A cavity transmitter which can remotely modulate proportionately the voltage of the receiver with the cavity distance transversed.

    Versatility could be enhanced by duplicating some of the functions by a smartphone app, i.e. dial a prostate/phallic orgasm while one is doing other chores, like attending Sunday school or driving, typing… While physical virus like HIV will be avoided, computer virus could be catastrophic like busting one’s ass…

  3. Lesbian HIV rates have to be fairly low. Lower, I would suspect, than even heterosexual female HIV cases.

    However, men DO contract HIV from anal sex with women. This has happened in the porn industry on several occasions.

  4. ErikThe Red

    Great detailed and informative response Robert. Yes, I meant penetrating.

  5. What the fuck is the big deal with anal, anyway? It’s just another hole, maybe slightly tighter than a vagina, but it’s the hole where fecal matter comes out, which is fucking disgusting.

    As for ladyboys, well just watching them do a handjob on themselves and cumming is enough for me. I have no desire to penetrate them anally nor get penetrated anally. Nor is a blowjob that great from them either. Although I admit it is pretty exciting to get a blowjob from a ladyboy but I would only do that with a condom. Best is to just watch them handjobbing themselves and cumming, that is fucking hot as fuck.

    • With women, once you push past the woman’s anal sphincter you cannot feel anything anyhow because your penis is in her colon. It’s like a huge cavernous vagina with a tight entrance.

      You would not know this because you are a frustrated Indian college student with too much time on his hands because Indian women just don’t put out any sex before marriage and you have to waste your youth on sites like this playing Devil’s Advocate.

      One thing about whites-we have a lot more fun than other races in our youth. We have more money and face less danger than blacks or hispanics but have more sex experiences than Asians.

    • ErikThe Red

      I’d rather have sex than watch a guy jerkoff.

  6. MAGNETO You like watching men in drag stroking their big penis and their sperm shooting out…they have to have big balls, right?

    Well, if you are gay….Which you are not because you are only an Indian college kid with too much time on his hands…because you never get sex with women.

    I feel sorry for Indian guys like you. Your youth is filled with sitting behind a computer and masturbation because you have no money for prostitutes and Indian women are unavailable.

    At your age you should be getting laid in discos and running around with women but of course Indian young men don’t have this chance.

    Sad really.

  7. Sami

    “Semen is… full of blood (little known fact).”


    I’ve never noticed any red or pink in my semen. Although, I guess it is kind of plasma-colored. Do you mean blood plasma plus white blood cells (to protect the sperm)? If you mean whole blood, where does this come from?

    Just curious. Tended to sleep in biology classes, and switched from pre-med to mechanical engineering early on in my college career.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s