The rejection of the Aryan Migration Theory to India in connection with Indo-European languages is nearly universal among intelligent and intellectual Indians, particularly high castes. The only support for the AMT among Indians is found among low castes, particularly Dalits.
It is now spreading to other anti-Whites. As I noted in an earlier post, a anti-White White commenter has recently signed on to rejection of the AMT, probably only because it is an anti-White theory. Huax, an anti-White Chinese nationalist in the comments, has also signed on recently. Probably his only reason for rejection of the AMT that that is the proper anti-White position.
A common thread here is that the AMT is a White Supremacist theory. However, it’s rare to meet a White Supremacist who subscribes to it. In fact, I’ve never in my life met one who talks about the “White Aryans” of Central and South Asia.
But it’s important to note that rejection of AMT automatically implies the Out of India Theory for Indo-European. You can’t have native Aryans in India without an OIT. While rejection of AMT is fashionable or even hip among all sorts of White-haters, the OIT is surely fringe stuff. But one leads to the other, as surely as night follows day.
Here is a recent comment by one of these Hindutva fascists. I had to edit it extensively because the guy is apparently an illiterate. My comments follow.
lol,. a typical white person response a culture based on the view that white must be superior classes everyone else as inferior…lol… amazing how a white guy with no real culture in India, has no knowledge of Indian culture, history, traditions, other than what hes read to confirm that the great Indian empires and civilizations somehow where connected with white people. lol…Krishna is a dark skinned god, not white, color in India does not refer to skin but to color of actions, you stupid white fool, white being the color of god, hence at funerals all Indians wear white, but Europeans wear black…Its so obvious that their is no white homeland, its obvious that the oldest sites for human civilization are in India, it was the Indians who left India that became the Europeans, and central Asian.
White people with looting of empires of old have not only tried to SCRIPT the history of the past as well as the plunder of each nation…This is the ideology of a ROTTEN shallow people, that’s why a group of white guys, raised in Taliban christian doctrine shipped over to India and they THINK THEY ARE THE ONES TO SCRIPT INDIAN HISTORY…
Why??…because Indian history is far greater than the Greeks the Romans and the Europeans, and hence to claim your stake the whites came up with the Aryan theory…lol…
Go to any place in Europe their is no Aryan culture present no Vedic culture present, read the bible and it has verses from the rig Veda, these white people want PEOPLE TO leave their own logic and sense and want others to believe that a barbaric tribe from nowhere land came aka Europe and overtook India the greatest and most powerful land on earth…lol…
M17 R1A1 all originate in India, India Ganges plain has the an equal claim to be the first to create agriculture, the ideology of Veda are only present in India, the destruction of the supposed Aryan theory that caste was imposed by the Aryans has been completely shattered.
More and more evidence supports the Indian who have no NEED TO CONFIRM THEIR IDENTITY, BUT WHEN A FOREIGN TALIBAN STYLE ATTACK ON INDIAN CULTURE IS BEING LAUNCHED BY A group of white people who have no interest in Indian politics or history, or its society are INVESTING TIME AND MONEY IN AN ATTEMPT TO PUSH LIES AS TRUTHS TO THE POINT ITS BECOMES A REALITY…in the face of evidence.
Europeans were from north Indians, the Vedas name no name for India as India itself, the Vedas reject any foreign homeland for themselves, archeologically speaking their is no evidence what so ever for any invasion, but with every new evidence that breaks the old theory down, whites have a long history in denial and deceit, they create a new theory which is so loose and absurd that when an Indian makes claim along those same lines but actually has a greater claim in it they ridicule it…lmao…
In the end its this the white world robbed and pillaged the world, the roman empire is what most Europeans hold onto, a slave empire, that was destined to fail, the Greeks where inferior to Indian intellect though, that’s why the numbering system was formulated in India.
History confirms India’s position as one the most powerful, hence when the British landed in India, within 200 years it went from the richest land on earth to the poorest, and the UK went from the poorest to the richest, and with that trade of wealth.
The whites wanted to create a false history that can now match the carpets and curtains, so just as they scripted Indian history to make them the creators, today Indians must revers the damage done by Nazi christian Taliban mindset that was created with the bloodshed of millions of Indian and the plunder of trillions of dollars.
India is returning back to its roots of greatness, and Europe with all its slave trade monies running out, is realizing why Asia has always been that land of the first and greatest civilizations. And with that India will break free from the slave chain of a people that have not only corrupted world societies but have the arrogance to think that they created the Asian empires, when Europe itself is contains nothing but scenarios.
Theory about this about that, a theory about how white Europeans were the first in the Americans, or about how white Europeans have a duty to enslave the black Negroes, or a theory on how the pyramids where built by white people not colored, or about how white people are superior than others., or about how white people created world civilization but history shows something completely different.
One day the DHARMIC REPUBLIC OF INDIA WILL RETURN and then we will shove every single genetic code down your throat…in the Vedas it states tribes from India where sent out, yet the same white people Europeans overlook such matters and then instead use selected passages to confirm their positions…what a joke…!!lol
Caste has been proven to be a system of governance that predates ANY ARYAN CLAIM…it’s native to India…another BLAST FROM EVIDENCE PAST that destroyed the HITLER white mentality, they defeated Hitler only because similar white Hitlers wanted it so. It was no fight for freedom it was a fight between world oppressors….
Just look at Europe today, it cannot cope with immigrants…if it where not for the fact the European governments allow such immigration shows how shallow white society is, with such loose roots, YOU NEED IMMIGRATION to generate wealth for your European culture. There is a reason why India and china has the largest populations…
THEY HAVE BEEN HERE THE LONGEST WITH CIVILIZATIONS that just didn’t crumble. Hence India holds ONTO ITS VEDIC ROOTS…whereas Europe converted to Christianity rejects any NOTION OF VEDIC CULTURE and today they wanna stake a claim having realise that the roots of European take them back to India, so Europeans take the location and move it upwards to central Asia, Russia…just enough distance to be with white people and just within enough distance of India the colored race…GENIUS.
It’s hard to say where to begin here.
The common thread here is that India is the cradle of all civilization. Many go further and state that India is the cradle of all humanity.
Agriculture surely did not originate in India. It originated in Papua New Guinea, Mexico, Egypt and China all around the same time, but not in India.
Note the now common line that all Europeans originally came from India. Ok, how come we don’t look like a bunch of elephant jockeys then?
Recently there has been a lot of talk of “Vedic” cultures in Europe dating back thousands of years. Supposedly one has been found in Croatia.
The Indo-Aryan homeland in Kazakhstan has a few sites that are now being claimed by Indians. Some of these sites were fairly modern architecturally in terms of indoor ovens, etc. The Indians insist that the nomads were too stupid to make these nice dwellings and that only superior Indians could have made them. They also say that swastikas have been found all over these old Indo-Aryan sites. This is apparently just more of their lies. The bottom line here apparently is an attempt to buttress the Out of India theory.
This typical argument throws up the usual red herrings. AMT is a White Supremacist, Nazi, Christian Taliban theory that is similar to the lines that Whites had a right to enslave Blacks, that Whites were the first in the New World, and that Whites built ancient Egypt. Most of these are either dead or fringe theories.
The notion that the hated White lands of Europe and America would be nowhere today without those glorious dark skinned immigrants, presumably Indians, is typical. It’s also probably nonsensical.
The use of ancient religious scriptures, of all things, to make the case for linguistic, archeological and anthropological facts is also typical.
There is a strain of Third Worldism and Dependency Theory in the notion that the wealth of the West is all stolen slave money from the exploited Third World.
The notion that India used to be the wealthiest and greatest land on Earth until it was ruined by evil British colonialists is typical.
Now it will rise, Phoenix-like, from the ashes of the ruins that its enemies have created for it, to rule the world and seek revenge on its enemies. This is classic fascist theory and you will note how similar it is to the classical fascism of Hitler and Mussolini. Indian nationalism is profoundly fascist; in fact, it is surely one of the larges and most dangerous fascist movement on Earth today, since it has the support of the overwhelming majority of intelligent, educated and intellectual Indians. Fascist Indian nationalism may well have 10’s of millions of fanatical followers.
Vedic culture is only present in India because that is where it was created. 3,900 YBP, Aryans migrated into North India, mixing with the native Dravidians and supplanting their languages. It was this mixture of nomadic Aryan pastoralists with Dravidian high culture that created Vedic culture.
Whether or not caste was brought to India by the Aryans or whether this rotten custom was already present is not known, but at any rate, it is not necessary to postulate that Aryans brought caste to India to support the AMT.
We see the familiar line, that the notion that the “great” Indian cultures of the past were created by the hated White man is the ultimate insult to Indian pride.
Note the extreme hatred for Christianity. This is typical of Hindutva ideologues. Christianity is associated with the diabolical Europeans who colonized and ruined India. Further, Christianity is a deadly threat to the great Hindu religion. Hindutvas carry out frequent attacks on Indian Christians, accusing them of converting Dalits to Christianity. Many Indian Christians have been murdered by Hindutvas, and Hindutvas have burned down entire Christian villages.
The notion that a “barbaric tribe from nowhere land” – these would be the Central Asian Aryans – came down from the north and conquered the greatest culture on Earth – Indian culture – is just too insulting to bear. That these Aryans were “White people” makes the insult all the more searing.